This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision | ||
wiki:guide:reviewtypes [2024/02/05 13:36] jthurnham [Targeted Literature Reviews/Rapid Review] |
wiki:guide:reviewtypes [2024/06/04 15:54] (current) lukesims [Narrative Review] |
||
---|---|---|---|
Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
Note: only licensed users will be able to view beyond Synthesis (Outputs) of these nests. | Note: only licensed users will be able to view beyond Synthesis (Outputs) of these nests. | ||
- | {{: | + | {{ :undefined:review_types_guide_image.png?nolink& |
===== Systematic Literature Review (SLR) ===== | ===== Systematic Literature Review (SLR) ===== | ||
- | The first review type we have to mention is the glorious SLR. A comprehensive and methodical approach, SLRs systematically gather, appraise, and synthesize existing literature to answer specific research questions. Nested Knowledge provides a structured framework to facilitate the rigorous process of SLRs, ensuring clarity and transparency in evidence synthesis. See our [[wiki: | + | The first review type we have to mention is the glorious SLR. A comprehensive and methodical approach, SLRs systematically gather, appraise, and synthesize existing literature to answer specific research questions. Nested Knowledge provides a structured framework to facilitate the rigorous process of SLRs, ensuring clarity and transparency in evidence synthesis. See our [[:wiki: |
Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
+ | |||
* Librarian-assisted search query built for **Literature Search** | * Librarian-assisted search query built for **Literature Search** | ||
* Run automatic search on a schedule for a living SLR | * Run automatic search on a schedule for a living SLR | ||
- | * Toggle on **Dual Two-Pass Screening** mode in Settings | + | * Toggle on **Dual Two-Pass Screening** |
- | * Turn on **Robot Screener** in Settings when recall reaches appropriate threshold | + | * Turn on **Robot Screener** |
- | * Set up **Tag Hierarchy** with pre-determined PICOs | + | * Set up **Tag Hierarchy** |
- | * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** for assistance in Tagging/ | + | * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** |
- | * Use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias | + | * Use a **Critical Appraisal** |
* Download Exports: Tags in **Study Inspector** | * Download Exports: Tags in **Study Inspector** | ||
* Assess and present evidence in **Qualitative Synthesis** | * Assess and present evidence in **Qualitative Synthesis** | ||
Line 27: | Line 29: | ||
===== Meta-analysis (including Network Meta-analysis) ===== | ===== Meta-analysis (including Network Meta-analysis) ===== | ||
- | A meta-analysis uses statistical methods to summarize the results of a systematic review. After completing your systematic review in Nested Knowledge, you can utilize [[wiki: | + | A meta-analysis uses statistical methods to summarize the results of a systematic review. After completing your systematic review in Nested Knowledge, you can utilize [[:wiki: |
Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
+ | |||
* Follow above steps to build an SLR | * Follow above steps to build an SLR | ||
- | * After completing **Tagging**, | + | * After completing **Tagging**, |
* Configure Interventions and Data Elements | * Configure Interventions and Data Elements | ||
- | * Complete MA Extraction to generate **Quantitative Synthesis** | + | * Complete MA Extraction to generate **Quantitative Synthesis** |
- | * **Download Exports:** Meta-Analytical Extracted Data in **Study Inspector** | + | * **Download Exports: |
* Assess and present evidence in Quantitative Synthesis for NMA outputs | * Assess and present evidence in Quantitative Synthesis for NMA outputs | ||
- | //View an example of [[https:// | + | //View an example of [[https:// |
- | // | + | |
===== HTA Submissions ===== | ===== HTA Submissions ===== | ||
Line 44: | Line 46: | ||
Nested Knowledge supports the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) process, largely catering to the clinical, epidemiological, | Nested Knowledge supports the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) process, largely catering to the clinical, epidemiological, | ||
- | **Clinical Effectiveness: | + | **Clinical Effectiveness: |
//View an example of [[https:// | //View an example of [[https:// | ||
- | **Epidemiology: | + | **Epidemiology: |
//View an example of [[https:// | //View an example of [[https:// | ||
- | **Economic evaluation/ | + | **Economic evaluation/ |
Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
+ | |||
* Topic-assisted search queries should be built for **Literature Search** | * Topic-assisted search queries should be built for **Literature Search** | ||
- | * Toggle on **Dual Two-Pass Screening** mode in Settings | + | * Toggle on **Dual Two-Pass Screening** |
- | * Set up **Tag Hierarchy** with pre-determined PICOs regardless of review type | + | * Set up **Tag Hierarchy** |
* Clinical reviews may involve MA Extraction and NMA, but Epidemiology and Cost-effectiveness reviews only involve Tagging | * Clinical reviews may involve MA Extraction and NMA, but Epidemiology and Cost-effectiveness reviews only involve Tagging | ||
- | * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** for assistance in Tagging/ | + | * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** |
- | * Use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias | + | * Use a **Critical Appraisal** |
* Download Exports/ | * Download Exports/ | ||
* Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis outputs** | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis outputs** | ||
Line 71: | Line 74: | ||
Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
+ | |||
* Rapidly check the PICOs of the search and build out strategy in **Search Exploration**, | * Rapidly check the PICOs of the search and build out strategy in **Search Exploration**, | ||
- | * Toggle **Standard, Single Screening** mode in Settings | + | * Toggle **Standard, Single Screening** |
* Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening model in Settings, which will activate once 50 records are screened | * Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening model in Settings, which will activate once 50 records are screened | ||
* Apply a bulk action including records above assigned threshold and excluding below assigned threshold | * Apply a bulk action including records above assigned threshold and excluding below assigned threshold | ||
- | * Configure **Tag Hierarchy** with only specific set of questions | + | * Configure **Tag Hierarchy** |
* Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations** | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations** | ||
* Apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, | * Apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, | ||
- | * If necessary, use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias | + | * If necessary, use a **Critical Appraisal** |
* Download Exports/ | * Download Exports/ | ||
- | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs | + | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** |
//View an example of [[https:// | //View an example of [[https:// | ||
Line 103: | Line 107: | ||
* Depending on your project, you may wish to use Dashboard or Manuscript | * Depending on your project, you may wish to use Dashboard or Manuscript | ||
- | //View an example of a Scoping Review in Nested Knowledge.// | + | //View an example of a [[https:// |
===== Narrative Review ===== | ===== Narrative Review ===== | ||
- | For researchers aiming to conduct an extensive description and interpretation of previously published writing on a chosen topic. Narrative reviews provide a flexible and rigorous approach to analysing | + | For researchers aiming to conduct an extensive description and interpretation of previously published writing on a chosen topic. Narrative reviews provide a flexible and rigorous approach to analyzing |
Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
Line 113: | Line 117: | ||
* Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration** | * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration** | ||
* Toggle **Dual Standard Screening** | * Toggle **Dual Standard Screening** | ||
- | * Turn on **Robot Screener** in Settings, once 50 records are screened | + | * Turn on **Robot Screener** |
* Auto-adjudicate Robot Screener agreements and adjudicate disagreements | * Auto-adjudicate Robot Screener agreements and adjudicate disagreements | ||
* Configure tag hierarchy with General PICO template to encompass overarching, | * Configure tag hierarchy with General PICO template to encompass overarching, | ||
Line 123: | Line 127: | ||
* Depending on your project, you may wish to use Dashboard or Manuscript | * Depending on your project, you may wish to use Dashboard or Manuscript | ||
- | //View an example of a Narrative Review in Nested Knowledge.// | + | //View an example of a [[https:// |
===== Gap Analysis ===== | ===== Gap Analysis ===== | ||
Line 130: | Line 134: | ||
Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
+ | |||
* Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration** | * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration** | ||
- | * Toggle **Standard, Single Screening** mode in Settings | + | * Toggle **Standard, Single Screening** |
* Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening model in Settings, which will activate once 50 records are screened | * Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening model in Settings, which will activate once 50 records are screened | ||
* Apply a bulk action including records above assigned threshold and excluding below assigned threshold | * Apply a bulk action including records above assigned threshold and excluding below assigned threshold | ||
- | * Configure **Tag hierarchy** with high specificity to identify gaps | + | * Configure **Tag hierarchy** |
* Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations** | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations** | ||
* Either manually accept/ | * Either manually accept/ | ||
- | * If necessary, use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias | + | * If necessary, use a **Critical Appraisal** |
* Download Exports/ | * Download Exports/ | ||
- | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs | + | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** |
- | //View an example of a Gap Analysis in Nested Knowledge.// | + | //View an example of a [[https:// |
Now that we've defined each review type, take a look at the following visual to decide what review type is best for your project and explore the features tailored to each methodology in Nested Knowledge. | Now that we've defined each review type, take a look at the following visual to decide what review type is best for your project and explore the features tailored to each methodology in Nested Knowledge. | ||
+ | |||
+ |