Nested Knowledge

Bringing Systematic Review to Life

User Tools

Site Tools


wiki:guide:qc

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
wiki:guide:qc [2022/02/03 20:40]
khutchison [Extraction]
wiki:guide:qc [2022/04/18 21:05] (current)
khutchison
Line 24: Line 24:
  
 In the case that the study should not be included, note the reason that exclusion is recommended for secondary review. In the case that the study should not be included, note the reason that exclusion is recommended for secondary review.
 +
 +When performing an SR/MA, you should also be sure that it does not have an excessively small or excessively large number of included studies. Always seek input from a statistician on this matter, as an "appropriate size" for an SR/MA is highly variable and depends on the specific study design and client requests. Generally speaking, you might expect a meta-analysis with inferential statistics to include anywhere from 4 to 50 studies.
  
 ===== Extraction ===== ===== Extraction =====
Line 44: Line 46:
   * Continuous data elements are being reported using the incorrect statistical measure (standard error is not the same as standard deviation)   * Continuous data elements are being reported using the incorrect statistical measure (standard error is not the same as standard deviation)
   * Make sure that elements are being extracted at the same time point or that the wording of the study is consistent with what is being collected (ex: 30-day mortality is not the same as 90-day mortality). Clarify if unsure of what the time point of interest is. Look out for inconsistencies across studies and note if there are timepoints that are commonly reported but are missed.   * Make sure that elements are being extracted at the same time point or that the wording of the study is consistent with what is being collected (ex: 30-day mortality is not the same as 90-day mortality). Clarify if unsure of what the time point of interest is. Look out for inconsistencies across studies and note if there are timepoints that are commonly reported but are missed.
- 
  
 ===== Statistical Errors and Clarifications ===== ===== Statistical Errors and Clarifications =====
Line 50: Line 51:
 QC requires a thorough understanding of the statistical measurements that are encountered when reading scientific literature. Refer to the following list if clarification is needed. QC requires a thorough understanding of the statistical measurements that are encountered when reading scientific literature. Refer to the following list if clarification is needed.
  
-**Mean **- The average of a set of numbers. This measure can be combined across populations if there are two means reported. This is NOT the same thing as Least Square (LS) mean. +| <font 11pt/inherit;;black;;inherit>Mean</font>     |The average of a set of numbers. This measure can be combined across populations if there are two means reported. This is NOT the same thing as Least Square (LS) mean.| 
- +| <font 11pt/inherit;;black;;inherit>Median</font>     |The middle value of a listed set of numbers. This measure can not be combined or used as a mean.| 
-**Median** - The middle value of a listed set of numbers. This measure can not be combined or used as a mean. +| <font 11pt/inherit;;black;;inherit>Standard Deviation (SD)</font>     |A measure of the amount of variance within a set of numbers. Typically reported with a mean value using the symbol '±'| 
- +| <font 11pt/inherit;;black;;inherit>Standard Error (SE)</font>     |The standard deviation of a sample of the larger population. This is NOT the same thing as SD and should not be used in replacement of SD.| 
-**Standard Deviation (SD)** - A measure of the amount of variance within a set of numbers. Typically reported with a mean value using the symbol '**±'** +| <font 11pt/inherit;;black;;inherit>Range</font>     |The difference between the highest and lowest numbers in a given set. Typically given alongside the median.| 
- +| <font 11pt/inherit;;black;;inherit>Interquartile Range (IQR)</font>     |The difference between the upper and lower quartiles. This is NOT the same thing as Range and should not be used as a replacement.|
-**Standard Error (SE)** - The standard deviation of a sample of the larger population. This is NOT the same thing as SD and should not be used in replacement of SD. +
- +
-**Range** - The difference between the highest and lowest numbers in a given set. Typically given alongside the median. +
- +
-**Interquartile Range (IQR)** - The difference between the upper and lower quartiles. This is NOT the same thing as Range and should not be used as a replacement. +
  
 ====== NK-specific QC ====== ====== NK-specific QC ======
  
-// To be done in addition to steps outlined above.  //+//To be done in addition to steps outlined above. //{{:wiki:guide:qc_checklist_for_wikis.docx|qc_checklist_for_wikis.docx}}
  
 ===== Tagging ===== ===== Tagging =====
Line 83: Line 78:
  
   * Let the team or project lead know that QC is complete and include notes and recommendations in the email.   * Let the team or project lead know that QC is complete and include notes and recommendations in the email.
-  * In the Nest Comments, type up a QC report detailing any changes that have made to the nest and any clarifications or new standards that have been set. Recomendations should not be included in the QC report, only actions that were taken. Include the date that QC was completed.+  * In the Nest Comments, type up a QC report detailing any changes that have made to the nest and any clarifications or new standards that have been set. Recommendations should not be included in the QC report, only actions that were taken. Include the date that QC was completed.
  
  
wiki/guide/qc.1643920858.txt.gz · Last modified: 2022/02/03 20:40 by khutchison