wiki:guide:reviewtypes
Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
| Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision | ||
|
wiki:guide:reviewtypes [2024/01/05 16:00] jthurnham |
wiki:guide:reviewtypes [2024/02/05 13:56] (current) jthurnham [Guidance on Review Types] |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
| Note: only licensed users will be able to view beyond Synthesis (Outputs) of these nests. | Note: only licensed users will be able to view beyond Synthesis (Outputs) of these nests. | ||
| - | * **Systematic Literature Review (SLR):** | + | {{ : |
| + | ===== Systematic Literature Review (SLR) ===== | ||
| The first review type we have to mention is the glorious SLR. A comprehensive and methodical approach, SLRs systematically gather, appraise, and synthesize existing literature to answer specific research questions. Nested Knowledge provides a structured framework to facilitate the rigorous process of SLRs, ensuring clarity and transparency in evidence synthesis. See our [[wiki: | The first review type we have to mention is the glorious SLR. A comprehensive and methodical approach, SLRs systematically gather, appraise, and synthesize existing literature to answer specific research questions. Nested Knowledge provides a structured framework to facilitate the rigorous process of SLRs, ensuring clarity and transparency in evidence synthesis. See our [[wiki: | ||
| Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
| - | * Librarian-assisted search query built for Literature Search | + | * Librarian-assisted search query built for **Literature Search** |
| * Run automatic search on a schedule for a living SLR | * Run automatic search on a schedule for a living SLR | ||
| - | * Toggle on Dual Two-Pass Screening mode in Settings | + | * Toggle on **Dual Two-Pass Screening** mode in Settings |
| - | * Turn on Robot Screener in Settings when recall reaches appropriate threshold | + | * Turn on **Robot Screener** in Settings when recall reaches appropriate threshold |
| - | * Set up Tag Hierarchy with pre-determined PICOs | + | * Set up **Tag Hierarchy** with pre-determined PICOs |
| - | * Turn on Smart Tag Recommendations for assistance in Tagging/ | + | * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** for assistance in Tagging/ |
| - | * Download Exports: Tags in Study Inspector | + | * Use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias |
| - | * Assess and present evidence in Qualitative Synthesis | + | * Download Exports: Tags in **Study Inspector** |
| + | * Assess and present evidence in **Qualitative Synthesis** | ||
| //View an example of [[https:// | //View an example of [[https:// | ||
| - | * **Meta-analysis (including Network Meta-analysis):** | + | ===== Meta-analysis (including Network Meta-analysis) |
| A meta-analysis uses statistical methods to summarize the results of a systematic review. After completing your systematic review in Nested Knowledge, you can utilize [[wiki: | A meta-analysis uses statistical methods to summarize the results of a systematic review. After completing your systematic review in Nested Knowledge, you can utilize [[wiki: | ||
| Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
| * Follow above steps to build an SLR | * Follow above steps to build an SLR | ||
| - | * After completing Tagging, toggle on Meta-Analytical Extraction in Settings | + | * After completing |
| * Configure Interventions and Data Elements | * Configure Interventions and Data Elements | ||
| - | * Complete MA Extraction to generate Quantitative Synthesis | + | * Complete MA Extraction to generate |
| - | * Download Exports: Meta-Analytical Extracted Data in Study Inspector | + | |
| * Assess and present evidence in Quantitative Synthesis for NMA outputs | * Assess and present evidence in Quantitative Synthesis for NMA outputs | ||
| Line 36: | Line 40: | ||
| // | // | ||
| - | * **HTA Submissions** | + | ===== HTA Submissions |
| Nested Knowledge supports the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) process, largely catering to the clinical, epidemiological, | Nested Knowledge supports the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) process, largely catering to the clinical, epidemiological, | ||
| Line 51: | Line 55: | ||
| Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
| - | * Topic-assisted search queries should be built for Literature Search | + | * Topic-assisted search queries should be built for **Literature Search** |
| - | * Toggle on Dual Two-Pass Screening mode in Settings | + | * Toggle on **Dual Two-Pass Screening** mode in Settings |
| - | * Set up Tag Hierarchy with pre-determined PICOs regardless of review type | + | * Set up **Tag Hierarchy** with pre-determined PICOs regardless of review type |
| * Clinical reviews may involve MA Extraction and NMA, but Epidemiology and Cost-effectiveness reviews only involve Tagging | * Clinical reviews may involve MA Extraction and NMA, but Epidemiology and Cost-effectiveness reviews only involve Tagging | ||
| - | * Turn on Smart Tag Recommendations for assistance in Tagging/ | + | * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** for assistance in Tagging/ |
| - | * Download Exports/ | + | * Use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias |
| - | * Assess and present evidence in Synthesis outputs | + | * Download Exports/ |
| + | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis outputs** | ||
| //View an example of incorporating [[https:// | //View an example of incorporating [[https:// | ||
| - | * **Targeted Literature Reviews/ | + | ===== Targeted Literature Reviews/ |
| When time is of the essence, Nested Knowledge facilitates targeted literature reviews and rapid reviews. Efficient and streamlined, | When time is of the essence, Nested Knowledge facilitates targeted literature reviews and rapid reviews. Efficient and streamlined, | ||
| Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
| - | * Rapidly check the PICOs of the search and build out strategy in Search Exploration, | + | * Rapidly check the PICOs of the search and build out strategy in **Search Exploration**, |
| - | * Toggle Standard, | + | * Toggle |
| - | * Turn on Robot Screener | + | * Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening model in Settings, which will activate |
| - | * Apply a bulk action | + | * Apply a bulk action |
| - | * Configure | + | * Configure |
| - | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text Smart Tag Recommendations | + | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations** |
| * Apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, | * Apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, | ||
| - | * Download Exports/ | + | |
| - | * Assess and present evidence in Synthesis outputs | + | |
| + | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs | ||
| //View an example of [[https:// | //View an example of [[https:// | ||
| - | * **Scoping Review:** | + | ===== Scoping Review |
| For researchers aiming to map the landscape of existing literature on a particular topic, Nested Knowledge provides tools for conducting scoping reviews. This approach helps define the breadth and depth of available evidence, setting the stage for more focused investigations. | For researchers aiming to map the landscape of existing literature on a particular topic, Nested Knowledge provides tools for conducting scoping reviews. This approach helps define the breadth and depth of available evidence, setting the stage for more focused investigations. | ||
| Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
| - | | + | |
| + | | ||
| * Set searches to run on a schedule to ensure comprehensive research import | * Set searches to run on a schedule to ensure comprehensive research import | ||
| - | * Toggle | + | * Toggle |
| - | * Turn on Robot Screener | + | * Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening Model in Settings, which will activate |
| - | * Apply a bulk action of accepting all Robot Screener recommendations | + | * Apply a bulk action of including studies above assigned threshold and excluding studies below threshold |
| * Configure tag hierarchy with General PICO template to encompass overarching, | * Configure tag hierarchy with General PICO template to encompass overarching, | ||
| - | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text Smart Tag Recommendations | + | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations** |
| * Either manually accept/ | * Either manually accept/ | ||
| - | * Download Exports/ | + | |
| - | * Assess and present evidence in Synthesis outputs | + | |
| + | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** | ||
| + | * Depending on your project, you may wish to use Dashboard or Manuscript | ||
| //View an example of a Scoping Review in Nested Knowledge.// | //View an example of a Scoping Review in Nested Knowledge.// | ||
| - | | + | ===== Narrative Review ===== |
| + | |||
| + | For researchers aiming to conduct an extensive description and interpretation of previously published writing on a chosen topic. Narrative reviews provide a flexible and rigorous approach to analysing and interpreting the literature in a written format. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
| + | |||
| + | | ||
| + | * Toggle **Dual Standard Screening** | ||
| + | * Turn on **Robot Screener** in Settings, once 50 records are screened | ||
| + | * Auto-adjudicate Robot Screener agreements and adjudicate disagreements | ||
| + | * Configure tag hierarchy with General PICO template to encompass overarching, | ||
| + | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations** | ||
| + | * Either manually accept/ | ||
| + | * Use a **Critical Appraisal** | ||
| + | * Download Exports/ | ||
| + | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** | ||
| + | * Depending on your project, you may wish to use Dashboard or Manuscript | ||
| + | |||
| + | //View an example of a Narrative Review in Nested Knowledge.// | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===== Gap Analysis ===== | ||
| Nested Knowledge supports researchers in identifying gaps in existing literature through comprehensive gap analyses. By systematically reviewing the current state of knowledge, researchers can pinpoint areas where further research is needed, contributing to the advancement of their respective fields. | Nested Knowledge supports researchers in identifying gaps in existing literature through comprehensive gap analyses. By systematically reviewing the current state of knowledge, researchers can pinpoint areas where further research is needed, contributing to the advancement of their respective fields. | ||
| Suggested Nest Setup: | Suggested Nest Setup: | ||
| - | * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in Search Exploration | + | * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration** |
| - | * Toggle Standard, | + | * Toggle |
| - | * Turn on Robot Screener | + | * Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening model in Settings, which will activate |
| - | * Apply a bulk action | + | * Apply a bulk action |
| - | * Configure Tag hierarchy with high specificity to identify gaps | + | * Configure |
| - | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text Smart Tag Recommendations | + | * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations** |
| * Either manually accept/ | * Either manually accept/ | ||
| - | * Download Exports/ | + | |
| - | * Assess and present evidence in Synthesis outputs | + | |
| + | * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs | ||
| //View an example of a Gap Analysis in Nested Knowledge.// | //View an example of a Gap Analysis in Nested Knowledge.// | ||
| Now that we've defined each review type, take a look at the following visual to decide what review type is best for your project and explore the features tailored to each methodology in Nested Knowledge. | Now that we've defined each review type, take a look at the following visual to decide what review type is best for your project and explore the features tailored to each methodology in Nested Knowledge. | ||
wiki/guide/reviewtypes.1704470420.txt.gz · Last modified: 2024/01/05 16:00 by jthurnham
Except where otherwise noted, content on this wiki is licensed under the following license: CC Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International
