Nested Knowledge

Bringing Systematic Review to Life

User Tools

Site Tools


wiki:guide:reviewtypes

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
wiki:guide:reviewtypes [2024/01/31 16:57]
jthurnham [Scoping Review]
wiki:guide:reviewtypes [2024/02/05 13:56] (current)
jthurnham [Guidance on Review Types]
Line 7: Line 7:
 Note: only licensed users will be able to view beyond Synthesis (Outputs) of these nests. Note: only licensed users will be able to view beyond Synthesis (Outputs) of these nests.
  
-{{:undefined:one-pager_1_.jpg?600|}}+{{ :undefined:review_types_guide_image.png?nolink |}}
 ===== Systematic Literature Review (SLR) ===== ===== Systematic Literature Review (SLR) =====
  
Line 19: Line 19:
   * Set up **Tag Hierarchy** with pre-determined PICOs   * Set up **Tag Hierarchy** with pre-determined PICOs
   * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** for assistance in Tagging/evidence collection   * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** for assistance in Tagging/evidence collection
 +  * Use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias
   * Download Exports: Tags in **Study Inspector**   * Download Exports: Tags in **Study Inspector**
   * Assess and present evidence in **Qualitative Synthesis**   * Assess and present evidence in **Qualitative Synthesis**
Line 59: Line 60:
   * Clinical reviews may involve MA Extraction and NMA, but Epidemiology and Cost-effectiveness reviews only involve Tagging   * Clinical reviews may involve MA Extraction and NMA, but Epidemiology and Cost-effectiveness reviews only involve Tagging
   * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** for assistance in Tagging/evidence collection   * Turn on **Smart Tag Recommendations** for assistance in Tagging/evidence collection
 +  * Use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias
   * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**   * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**
   * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis outputs**   * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis outputs**
Line 70: Line 72:
 Suggested Nest Setup: Suggested Nest Setup:
   * Rapidly check the PICOs of the search and build out strategy in **Search Exploration**,   * Rapidly check the PICOs of the search and build out strategy in **Search Exploration**,
-  * Toggle **Standard, Dual Screening** mode in Settings +  * Toggle **Standard, Single Screening** mode in Settings 
-  * Turn on **Robot Screener** in Settings once 50 records are screened +  * Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening model in Settings, which will activate once 50 records are screened 
-  * Apply a **bulk action** of accepting all Robot Screener recommendations+  * Apply a bulk action including records above assigned threshold and excluding below assigned threshold
   * Configure **Tag Hierarchy** with only specific set of questions   * Configure **Tag Hierarchy** with only specific set of questions
   * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations**   * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations**
   * Apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, non-quality-controlled outputs   * Apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, non-quality-controlled outputs
 +  * If necessary, use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias
   * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**   * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**
   * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs   * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs
Line 86: Line 89:
  
 Suggested Nest Setup: Suggested Nest Setup:
 +
   * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration**   * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration**
   * Set searches to run on a schedule to ensure comprehensive research import   * Set searches to run on a schedule to ensure comprehensive research import
-  * Toggle **Dual Two Pass Screening** mode in Settings +  * Toggle **Single Two Pass Screening**  mode in Settings 
-  * Turn on **Robot Screener** in Settings once 50 records are screened +  * Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening Model in Settings, which will activate once 50 records are screened 
-  * Apply a bulk action of accepting all Robot Screener recommendations+  * Apply a bulk action of including studies above assigned threshold and excluding studies below threshold
   * Configure tag hierarchy with General PICO template to encompass overarching, scoping questions   * Configure tag hierarchy with General PICO template to encompass overarching, scoping questions
   * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations**   * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations**
   * Either manually accept/reject recommendations or apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, non-quality-controlled outputs   * Either manually accept/reject recommendations or apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, non-quality-controlled outputs
 +  * Use a **Critical Appraisal**  system to assess Risk of Bias
   * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**   * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**
-  * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs+  * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis**  outputs 
 +  * Depending on your project, you may wish to use Dashboard or Manuscript
  
 //View an example of a Scoping Review in Nested Knowledge.// //View an example of a Scoping Review in Nested Knowledge.//
 +
 +===== Narrative Review =====
 +
 +For researchers aiming to conduct an extensive description and interpretation of previously published writing on a chosen topic. Narrative reviews provide a flexible and rigorous approach to analysing and interpreting the literature in a written format.
 +
 +Suggested Nest Setup:
 +
 +  * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration**
 +  * Toggle **Dual Standard Screening**  mode in Settings
 +  * Turn on **Robot Screener** in Settings, once 50 records are screened
 +  * Auto-adjudicate Robot Screener agreements and adjudicate disagreements
 +  * Configure tag hierarchy with General PICO template to encompass overarching, scoping questions
 +  * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations**
 +  * Either manually accept/reject recommendations or apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, non-quality-controlled outputs
 +  * Use a **Critical Appraisal**  system to assess Risk of Bias
 +  * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**
 +  * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis**  outputs
 +  * Depending on your project, you may wish to use Dashboard or Manuscript
 +
 +//View an example of a Narrative Review in Nested Knowledge.//
  
 ===== Gap Analysis ===== ===== Gap Analysis =====
Line 105: Line 131:
 Suggested Nest Setup: Suggested Nest Setup:
   * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration**   * Enter broad PICO terms and build out initial search query in **Search Exploration**
-  * Toggle **Standard, Dual Screening** mode in Settings +  * Toggle **Standard, Single Screening** mode in Settings 
-  * Turn on **Robot Screener** in Settings once 50 records are screened +  * Turn on Automatic Training of the Screening model in Settings, which will activate once 50 records are screened 
-  * Apply a bulk action of accepting all Robot Screener recommendations+  * Apply a bulk action including records above assigned threshold and excluding below assigned threshold
   * Configure **Tag hierarchy** with high specificity to identify gaps   * Configure **Tag hierarchy** with high specificity to identify gaps
   * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations**   * Turn on Abstract or Full Text **Smart Tag Recommendations**
   * Either manually accept/reject recommendations or apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, non-quality-controlled outputs   * Either manually accept/reject recommendations or apply a bulk action of accepting all tag recommendations to create preliminary, non-quality-controlled outputs
 +  * If necessary, use a **Critical Appraisal** system to assess Risk of Bias
   * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**   * Download Exports/Spreadsheets in **Study Inspector**
   * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs   * Assess and present evidence in **Synthesis** outputs
wiki/guide/reviewtypes.1706720239.txt.gz · Last modified: 2024/01/31 16:57 by jthurnham